Sunday, February 23, 2014

BOOK REVIEW: "The Art of Fiction" by Ayn Rand

Choosing to read either Ayn Rand's The Art of Nonfiction or The Art of Fiction is tricky. The Art of Nonfiction relies greatly on fiction passages, notably Rand's, to illustrate process, substance, structure, and style; nevertheless, it renders many profound insights about the writer's task. (Read my review of Rand's The Art of Nonfiction in this blog.) On the other hand, writers looking for inspiration and encouragement from a consummate professional will find it in abundance in The Art of Fiction.

Many of the points I made in The Art of Nonfiction applies to this book. For instance, Rand is extremely fond of herself as an exemplar of great literature. She writes, "In regard to precision of language, I think I myself am the best writer today." She is equally unforgiving of other writers, especially Sinclair Lewis. Once again, it's fair to say that Rand's two books, published posthumously, come from lectures that she delivered in her home exclusively to friends, so she never intended to publish them.


But you can't argue with quality. Early in the book, Rand offers a simple admonishment to would-be writers: "If a writer feels that he was unable fully to express what he wanted to express, it means that he did not know clearly what he wanted to express. ... That which you know clearly you can find the words for and you will express clearly." From there, she delves into Victor Hugo, Isak Dinesen, Mickey Spillane, and Thomas Wolfe, among others, to reflect on the do's and don'ts of style. 

In The Art of Fiction, Rand takes a refreshingly pragmatic and helpful approach to many writing topics. About the writer's muse, she notes, "If you keep on storing things in your mind for your future writing and keep integrating your choice of theme to your general knowledge, allowing the scope of writing to grow and your knowledge widens, then you will always have something to say, and you will find ever better ways to say it." Her strong opinions lead to uncompromising propositions, such as "The purpose of all art is the objectification of values."

Rand unflinchingly leaves herself open to criticism from literary theorists. Those who favor character as the premier element of fiction would find arguable her position, "The most important element of a novel is plot." Also, her division of style into the two categories of content and diction might puzzle those who argue that style is the sum of syntax and diction. 

Here are other Rand gems sprinkled throughout the 176 pages with in-depth illustrations:

  • Coincidence is always bad in writing, and it is disastrous in plot writing. ... it is to be avoided at all costs.
  • Concretize your abstractions.
  • Learn to think in terms of conflict.
  • If the essential situation ... can be told in one sentence, this makes for a good plot story.
  • Your characterization will never be better than your power of observation.
  • One of the beauties of a good literary style ... is that it combines clear denotation with the skillful use of connotation.
  • The purpose of metaphors, or comparison, is epistemological.
  • A symbol should be legible; otherwise, the form is a contradiction in terms. 
Fiction writers and students will find far more in this book than they would likely get in a semester-long writing class, unless they were lucky enough to attend Rand's lectures.

Sunday, February 16, 2014

Four Elements of an Audit Point—Really?

Good writing at work requires addressing the issues before anything else. The auditing world nicely illustrates this truth. The general operating principle for auditors is that an audit point includes four elements: criteria, condition, cause, and effect. These elements attempt to answer the following questions:

  • criteria — By what standards is the auditor assessing the situation?
  • condition — What is the situation?
  • cause — Why does the condition occur?
  • effect — To what risk does the condition expose the auditee? 

Here is an example:

XYZ Corporation should pay invoices within 30 days of the invoice date (criterion). XYZ pays invoices on average 45 days after the invoice date (condition) at the direction of management (cause). This delinquency could lead to poor vendor relations and subject XYZ to costly, time-consuming litigation (effect). 

But auditors should think twice if they believe that this audit point is comprehensive. They may need to consider other elements:

  • method — How did the auditor determine the condition?
  • limitation — What prevented the auditor from conducting a more thorough assessment?
  • finding — How would the auditor summarize the condition?
  • recommendation — What should the auditee do about the condition?
  • follow-up — How will the auditor address this finding in a future audit?
Let's see how the narrative has to change once these additional elements appear in the same audit point:

We examined a random sampling of 400 invoices and disbursements of the 1,975 total transactions (20.3%) of XYZ's West Coast office for the period January 15, 2014 to February 14, 2014 (method). Given the two-day audit schedule, we were unable to review a larger sampling or a longer period, and we did not review XYZ's East Coast office at all (limitation).

Our review shows that XYZ's West Coast office's Account Payable Department is delinquent in disbursing funds (finding). XYZ should pay invoices within 30 days of the invoice date (criteria). In the sample, XYZ paid invoices on average 45 days after the invoice date (condition) at the direction of management (cause). This delinquency could lead to poor vendor relations and subject XYZ to costly, time-consuming litigation (effect).

XYZ management should develop a mitigation plan to pay invoices within the contractually committed period and present it to the auditor within 30 days of this report (recommendation). In 90 days, we will return to XYZ to audit Accounts Payable disbursements for this criterion (follow-up).

The seasoned auditor would rightly say that even more elements exist (e.g., auditee response, aberrations, benefits), so less experienced auditors must understand that the four-element template is there just as a jumpstart, not as a complete formula.

Sunday, February 09, 2014

Reading Is Where It All Starts


I urge you to view this video of Sean Connery accepting the 2006 American Film Institute Lifetime Achievement Award. Since the video is 8 minutes and 16 seconds, the part to watch is a 40-second segment from 6:21 to 7:01 for those with limited time. 

Connery's words so simply and so brilliantly capture the transformative power of reading. The transcript of those 40 seconds appears below.

Sean Connery: I got my break—big break—when I was five years old, and it's taken me more than seventy years to realize it. You see, at five, I learned to read. It's that simple, and it's that profound. I left school at thirteen, I didn't have a formal education, and I believe I would not be standing here tonight without the books, the plays, the scripts.

Adults: Tell children this truth and live by it yourself.

Wednesday, February 05, 2014

Web-based Writing Course Log

A quick, easy, and inexpensive way to learn about writing these days is through webinars. I have designed and delivered synchronous and asynchronous online writing courses, webinars, or coaching programs for eight companies, which have made the content available only to their staff. But 14 of my one- to two-hour webinars and 4 live online courses for six other firms are online, all for free or at reasonable prices.

American Management Association (2 webinars, 4 live courses):

InfoComm International (2 webinars):

ComplianceOnline
(3 webinars) 
  • Business Writing for Financial Professionals –  Determine the appropriate level of detail, structure content for easy reader access, and heighten the relevance of facts.
  • Quality Writing for Technical Professionals (premieres March 11, 2014) – Strike a balance between conveying complex data to subject-matter experts and less technical readers. 
  • Report Writing for Auditing Professionals (premieres April 23, 2014) – Present criteria, conditions, causes, and effects with authority.

SmartPros (4 webinars)
  • Writing Effective and Efficient Email – Recognize five common email problems and identify the standards of an excellent email. 
  • Audit Report Writing – Create department-specific templates, cultivate a clear and concise vocabulary, and use syntax and diction tips.
  • Writing for Engineers – Determine content and style for diverse audiences, standardize documentation tasks, and summarize effectively.
  • Financial Business Writing – Organize messages with a practical structure, link key business points with logical transitions, and cultivate a fluent style. 

  • Emails: Writing Them Right – Employ a strategy for writing email effectively.
  • Audit Report Writing (premieres July 14, 2014) –Employ a vast toolbox of techniques when noting observations, drafting objective workpapers, and composing structured, comprehensive, and fluent audit reports.

Center for Competitive Management (1 webinar)

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

But Why Omaha?

During the National Football Conference championship game between the Denver Broncos and the New England Patriots, I googled "Why does Peyton Manning say Omaha?" During that game, which quarterback Manning's team won, he yelled "Omaha" more than 50 times before taking a snap from the center to begin a play. 

I was surprised to find that every reporter who weighed in on this word cared only about what Manning means when he shouts it, not why he chose it. We writers are always interested in why someone chooses one word over another. What I wanted to know is why he chose Omaha and not Cherokee, radio, pussycat, or any other word. Of course, everything a quarterback says when calling signals at the line of scrimmage is meant to deceive the opposing team. So why would Manning tell us why he says it? That leaves me with the more interesting question, at least for me, of why he, and his arch rival Tom Brady before him, chose Omaha.

The name Omaha is rich in American history. The American native Omaha people come to mind. Their tribe lost much of its land illegally in the nineteenth century during the Western expansion of the United States. We also associate the word with the code name Omaha Beach used by US forces on D-Day, June 6, 1944, when they assaulted beachheads in Normandy, France, resulting in the loss of many American and German lives. So did Manning choose Omaha because of the purely American or military imagery it conjures? For that matter, did he really think as much about the word as I have?

The Manning play call has certainly started a craze. Some companies with Omaha in their name are donating $500 to Manning's philanthropic foundation for every time he says the word in a game. The city of Omaha, Nebraska, keeps coming up with ways to capitalize on the welcomed attention it is getting as well. All things Omaha want to sign Manning to endorsement deals.

Anyway, you can enjoy the Super Bowl not only by keeping score of the game but by counting Manning's Omahas.

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Question What You Read—and Write

We have to read in a state of wide-awakeness, to use a term popularized by educational philosopher Maxine Greene. By wide-awakeness she means personal reflection, judging carefully and not accepting premises, methods, and results at face value. This idea so also applies to writing, which isn’t only about sentence fluency and grammatical correctness. It’s more importantly about objective analysis and sound thinking, and some of the most respected publications make serious blunders in these areas.

Case in point: The New York Times on January 23, 2014, printed an article about JPMorgan Chase Chairman and CEO Jamie Dimon getting a raise. Two flaws immediately surface in the article. Before mentioning them, I want to make clear that I am not taking sides with the man or the company. I am interested only in an equitable handling of facts regardless of the subject.  

The first occurs in the title: "Fined Billions, JPMorgan Chase Will Give Dimon a Raise." The article presumes to be a hard news story, which calls for an objective style. Yet it spews its opinion before the first sentence. Most semiconscious readers will have already formed an opinion of the company and its leader just from that headline. Even though the fines did occur under Mr. Dimon's watch, this rhetorical strategy is unfair. It is also true that the company's stock rose 22% in the past 12 months, so why didn't the headline read "A Year after Excellent Returns, JPMorgan Chase Will Give Dimon a Raise"? The answer must be that the newspaper has an ax to grind against the company and its leader. So much for objective analysis. An unbiased headline would have dropped the first two words. 

The second error arises toward the end of the article, which describes confrontational meetings pitting a minority of board members against giving Dimon the raise with a majority of board members in favor. The authors write, "During the meetings, some board members left the conference room to pace up and down the 50th floor corridor." Where's the sound reasoning here? Was the urge to pace the reason that they left the meeting? Did they simply want to vent? Were they satisfying a desire to get some exercise? Or were they pacing while talking to strategists on their mobile devices? Or trying to broker a deal with their adversaries? Instead of asserting that the board members had the intention of merely pacing a corridor, perhaps the reporters could have written, "During the meetings, some board members left the conference room, pacing up and down the 50th floor corridor, as they tried to reach an agreement." Better yet, the entire sentence could have been deleted.

So if we have to read in a state of wide-awakeness, how much more so when we write.

Saturday, January 18, 2014

Why Asking Questions Matters

In a May 27, 2008 interview with Charlie Rose, playwright Edward Albee said:
If you're going to spend a hundred bucks or more to go to the theater, something should happen to you. Maybe somebody should be asking some questions about your values or the way you think about things. And maybe you should come out of the theater (with) something having happened to you. Maybe you should be changing or thinking about changing. But if you just go there and the only thing you worry about is where you left the damn car, then you've wasted your hundred bucks.
Albee knows what he's talking about. Not only because at age 85, he is an American icon with plays that have earned three Pulitzer Prizes, two Tony awards, three New York Drama Critics Circle awards, a Drama Desk award, and numerous citations for lifetime achievement in the theater. He is clearly the sage because his observation applies to so many other facets of life. For instance, if we paraphrase the opening of his quote with "If you're going to spend a hundred minutes or more to watch television," we would never spend a minute on reality TV. Or "If you're going to spend a few thousand bucks or more to vacation somewhere," we would choose a national park or foreign city over Disney World. 

I strongly believe what Albee says relates to my writing classes. In the closing of this interview excerpt, he suggests that answers are often unreachable, but this reality should never prevent us from asking hard questions and exploring possible answers. Sometimes people in my classes will want the right answer for what they should include in a proposal, how they should organize a report, or how they should phrase a sentence. I can offer possibilities, but I'd be a fool to claim I have a definitive answer.

I meet a lot of course leaders who teach as though writing instruction were little more than a collection of rules in grammar, diction, and punctuation. Far from it. Even though these points do matter, they are less important than purposefulness, completeness, structure, and clarity.

My goal is to help people think through writing: to question their own assertions, to test commonly held beliefs, and to challenge their audience to see the value of alternative ideas. As a result, they will become not only more accomplished as writers but more masterful as residents of Earth. When I impart this mindset, my time was well spent; when my students achieve it, their time was too.